I will give Creationists their due - their arguments have become marginally more sophisticated since I first read their anti-Darwin screeds, but starting from zero they haven't had to come far. This is one of those books I can only read in small doses before the stupid starts to burn and I have to stop.
The first thing to remember when reading this book is that it is not meant to be a textbook, nor is it designed to inform. Rather, it is a guide for disrupting science lessons. Creationist teenagers are advised to team up and assail science teachers in tag teams, retaining Christ-like meekness as they seek to sabotage the education of their less religiously motivated classmates. The questions the book presents are not adequately answered (a link to answersingenesis.org is not an adequate answer), nor are they meant to be - the intellectual guerrillas for Jesus are instead urged to throw questions in the hope that the teachers will not know the answers, thereby undermining the credibility of Darwinism in front of openminded schoolkids.
In other words, this is a pretty disreputable book, using the tactics of the courtroom barrister and the spin doctor to achieve its objectives. If a textbook phrases a sentence just so, the book seizes on the literal meaning to set up a straw man and then knock it down. Some of these straw men are so obvious it is hard to ascribe it to the author's ingenuousness. If an evolutionary family tree, constructed from isolated specimens and fragmentary fossils, is amended even once, it means Darwin was wrong (a principle which does not apply to so-called Creation science such as Flood Geology, freely described as a work in progress). A fraudulent fossil put together by a sharp-eyed Chinese dealer not only disproves Darwinism but proves that scientists are dishonest. The old creationist tactic of referring to controversies long laid to rest as if they had not been resolved features strongly - this shabby volume pays homage to Fred Hoyle's half-baked allegation that Archaeopteryx is a fraud. The fact that Alan Charig and others demolished ol' Fred's gadfly speculation quarter of a century ago does not butter Patterson's parsnips.
Also egregious with the book's habit of referring to all pre-19th century scientists as 'Creationists', which most people were by default.
Creationist theory, such as it is, aims at reducing the gaps to which their God is confined. Where things are demonstrably true and where denial just looks plain mad, Creationists withdraw. But evolutionary theory is almost (but not quite) impossible to observe in action, so Creationists insist that there resides a gap for God to live in by using the smokescreen of loaded questions and wilful incomprehension.
But of course, 'disproving' Darwinism, a front on which even the Creationists can only hope for a stalemate, is not the ultimate aim. They want to indoctrinate your children and impose their belief system on them. This can only be good, they reason. After all, evolutionists and atheists are evil people who want to justify their own sinful and villainous lives by proving the non-existence of God. The book says as much, if you read it through and piece it together. I suppose we should be grateful that Darwin doesn't get blamed for the Holocaust until page 218. The book also accuses Darwin of fuelling racism rather than inventing it, no doubt aware of the risk of being accused of hypocrisy in that Genesis 9:25 was used to justify the abduction of millions of west Africans during the era of slavery, which ended before Darwin published his work.
All teachers interested in science need to read this book and if possible familiarise themselves with the questions posed and arm themselves with answers. Sadly, the best way to counteract its pernicious influence may be to buy it, if only to rubbish its assertions.
Sunday, 1 July 2012
Saturday, 9 June 2012
Luvilee Jubilee
Just a quick note to acknowledge the advent of 2012...I missed most of the Diamond Jubilee weekend due to work commitments (although I saw enough to make me think that it wasn't a patch on the Golden Jubilee) but I will say that there is immense benefit to having a head of state who stays in place for decades and about whom even the detractors can only find nice or neutral things to say.
The alternative would be to kick some superannuated politician upstairs to the post of head of state. The problem with that is that most politicians are, by their nature, divisive figures who would be detested by at least 50% of the population at any given moment.
This is not a recipe for stability, continuity, cohesion or indeed peace.
The alternative would be to kick some superannuated politician upstairs to the post of head of state. The problem with that is that most politicians are, by their nature, divisive figures who would be detested by at least 50% of the population at any given moment.
This is not a recipe for stability, continuity, cohesion or indeed peace.
Wednesday, 7 December 2011
Free Will and Risk Assessment
I haven't watched it yet, partly because I'm afraid to, but ITV ran a documentary on Monday commemorating the live TV tragedy which was the Nigel Benn-Gerald McClellan boxing match, which resulted in serious brain damage being suffered by the American fighter.
I have never wished to apologise for my enthusiasm for the noble art of self-defence but this bout, like the Eubank-Watson tragedy before it, leaves me with a profound sense of discomfort and a feeling of disjunction between love of the sport and its hideous consequences. Indeed, the Benn-McClellan bout would have ranked as an all-time great bout without its sequelae - epic excitement served with epic horror.
For those who never saw the bout, Nigel Benn was, in the early 1990s, Britain's most exciting pugilist. A never-say-die slugger, he was not as slick as Michael Watson, as strong as Chris Eubank nor a defensive genius like Herol Graham, but he was gutsy, aggressive, a pull-up-your-chair and wait-for-the-bell fighter. Benn live on TV made for an enjoyable evening.
But there was a feeling this time that Benn was showing signs of wear and tear, and McClellan was the new man on the block. A hard-hitting man who matched Benn for aggression, he had recently dethroned Julian Jackson, WBC Middleweight champ and possibly the hardest-hitting fighter of all time. Benn was a huge underdog; one British sports writer said he was going to hide in his cupboard until told McClellan had returned to the USA. Few rated Nigel's chances of upsetting his challenger.
When fight night came, and the opening bell rang, McClellan fired his big guns and knocked Benn clean out of the ring. Benn was pushed back in with the benefit of a long count, and McClellan resumed the attack.
But Benn weathered the storm and came back, matching McClellan blow for blow, until the tired American returned to the corner at the end of the 9th round, blinking hard.
Blinking hard. It didn't look right. His corner didn't seem to notice, nor the ref, nor the ringside doctor, nor the ITV commentators. But it looked bad to me, and I screamed at the TV for the referee to stop the fight.
It didn't work, of course. Gerald came out for the tenth and the fight was stopped shortly after. By this time he was suffering a brain haemorrhage which ultimately left him blind, deaf and paralysed.
He added the sorry roll-call of boxing's victims, McClellan and Watson, Rod Douglas and Young Ali and Goult and Anifowoshe and little Johnny Owen, suffering in oblivion under the hoots and catcalls of a Hispanic mob. How can this be allowed?
Whether we like it or not, people are going to engage in activities which threaten life and limb. Whether it's collapsing scrums in rugby, motorbike or car racing accidents, heading footballs or binge drinking or unsafe sex, all activities carry risk. In boxing the risks are more obvious and more acute, but maybe this militates against selecting boxing for banishment and outlawry. For no boxer can enter the ring ignorant of the dangers he may face. The same cannot be said for people engaging in football or cricket or promiscuity. Those are risks which can be ignored or of which we are collectively ignorant.
The only argument for outlawing dangerous sports or other activities is to protect the participants. An important part of this is allowing people to consent to participate with the full facts in mind. No sportsman has the risks more in mind than the boxer
The more dangerous the sport, then, the less need to ban them. And this is the sophistry which leads me to defend the pugilist's right to practice his art.
I have never wished to apologise for my enthusiasm for the noble art of self-defence but this bout, like the Eubank-Watson tragedy before it, leaves me with a profound sense of discomfort and a feeling of disjunction between love of the sport and its hideous consequences. Indeed, the Benn-McClellan bout would have ranked as an all-time great bout without its sequelae - epic excitement served with epic horror.
For those who never saw the bout, Nigel Benn was, in the early 1990s, Britain's most exciting pugilist. A never-say-die slugger, he was not as slick as Michael Watson, as strong as Chris Eubank nor a defensive genius like Herol Graham, but he was gutsy, aggressive, a pull-up-your-chair and wait-for-the-bell fighter. Benn live on TV made for an enjoyable evening.
But there was a feeling this time that Benn was showing signs of wear and tear, and McClellan was the new man on the block. A hard-hitting man who matched Benn for aggression, he had recently dethroned Julian Jackson, WBC Middleweight champ and possibly the hardest-hitting fighter of all time. Benn was a huge underdog; one British sports writer said he was going to hide in his cupboard until told McClellan had returned to the USA. Few rated Nigel's chances of upsetting his challenger.
When fight night came, and the opening bell rang, McClellan fired his big guns and knocked Benn clean out of the ring. Benn was pushed back in with the benefit of a long count, and McClellan resumed the attack.
But Benn weathered the storm and came back, matching McClellan blow for blow, until the tired American returned to the corner at the end of the 9th round, blinking hard.
Blinking hard. It didn't look right. His corner didn't seem to notice, nor the ref, nor the ringside doctor, nor the ITV commentators. But it looked bad to me, and I screamed at the TV for the referee to stop the fight.
It didn't work, of course. Gerald came out for the tenth and the fight was stopped shortly after. By this time he was suffering a brain haemorrhage which ultimately left him blind, deaf and paralysed.
He added the sorry roll-call of boxing's victims, McClellan and Watson, Rod Douglas and Young Ali and Goult and Anifowoshe and little Johnny Owen, suffering in oblivion under the hoots and catcalls of a Hispanic mob. How can this be allowed?
Whether we like it or not, people are going to engage in activities which threaten life and limb. Whether it's collapsing scrums in rugby, motorbike or car racing accidents, heading footballs or binge drinking or unsafe sex, all activities carry risk. In boxing the risks are more obvious and more acute, but maybe this militates against selecting boxing for banishment and outlawry. For no boxer can enter the ring ignorant of the dangers he may face. The same cannot be said for people engaging in football or cricket or promiscuity. Those are risks which can be ignored or of which we are collectively ignorant.
The only argument for outlawing dangerous sports or other activities is to protect the participants. An important part of this is allowing people to consent to participate with the full facts in mind. No sportsman has the risks more in mind than the boxer
The more dangerous the sport, then, the less need to ban them. And this is the sophistry which leads me to defend the pugilist's right to practice his art.
Thursday, 1 December 2011
Free Speech and the Trade Union Movement
One of the biggest problems with anti-defamation legislation is that, in attempting to cope with Lernaean nature of ideological bigotry, it tends to start off casting a wide net and ends in being abused by the politically interested to enforce censorship and to stifle freedom of expression. This is done not so much for the suppression of particular statements as it is to engender a climate of fear and to ensure compliance with some political stance or other.
This has been illustrated amply today by the Unison trade union, with their frankly bizarre over-reaction to petrol-head buffoon Jeremy Clarkson's voicing of an opinion that striking public workers should be dragged in front of their families and shot.
Let's break this down. Firstly, Clarkson is saying that he disagrees with the strike. Not a hugely unpopular stance, especially with those whose private pensions were pillaged a decade ago by Unison's buddies in the Labour government, and at present not voicing support for the left is not a criminal offence, however much the TUC may wish it to be.
Secondly, Clarkson was making the tongue-in-cheek suggestion that people he disagrees with should be shot. Over the top, but it was a joke, and the political left have always made similar statements ("you'll be the first against the wall when the revolution comes" etc).
But according to some witch-faced old harridan on BBC News at Lunchtime, that is 'incitement to hatred' and Unison is taking legal advice over it.
Clarkson has, probably under BBC pressure, issued an apology, which is kind of mission accomplished for the Marxists in the trade union movement. But Clarkson and others who feel the same way may wish to watch TV footage of union picket lines, student demonstrations and anti-capitalist sit-ins for evidence of signs saying "Eat the Rich!" or "Hang the bankers!" and dial 101 when they spot one. After all, despite what commies might think, sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander, and if a BBC journalist can be threatened with legal action for 'incitement to hatred', then why not a Unison shop steward, or a student, or a Tarquin or Cressida playing anarchists?
If someone slaps you round the face, you don't turn the other cheek, you smash his face in. Unison slapped Clarkson and the concept of freedom of expression today. Make the unions eat their teeth.
Now that's hatred.
This has been illustrated amply today by the Unison trade union, with their frankly bizarre over-reaction to petrol-head buffoon Jeremy Clarkson's voicing of an opinion that striking public workers should be dragged in front of their families and shot.
Let's break this down. Firstly, Clarkson is saying that he disagrees with the strike. Not a hugely unpopular stance, especially with those whose private pensions were pillaged a decade ago by Unison's buddies in the Labour government, and at present not voicing support for the left is not a criminal offence, however much the TUC may wish it to be.
Secondly, Clarkson was making the tongue-in-cheek suggestion that people he disagrees with should be shot. Over the top, but it was a joke, and the political left have always made similar statements ("you'll be the first against the wall when the revolution comes" etc).
But according to some witch-faced old harridan on BBC News at Lunchtime, that is 'incitement to hatred' and Unison is taking legal advice over it.
Clarkson has, probably under BBC pressure, issued an apology, which is kind of mission accomplished for the Marxists in the trade union movement. But Clarkson and others who feel the same way may wish to watch TV footage of union picket lines, student demonstrations and anti-capitalist sit-ins for evidence of signs saying "Eat the Rich!" or "Hang the bankers!" and dial 101 when they spot one. After all, despite what commies might think, sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander, and if a BBC journalist can be threatened with legal action for 'incitement to hatred', then why not a Unison shop steward, or a student, or a Tarquin or Cressida playing anarchists?
If someone slaps you round the face, you don't turn the other cheek, you smash his face in. Unison slapped Clarkson and the concept of freedom of expression today. Make the unions eat their teeth.
Now that's hatred.
Monday, 29 August 2011
The Plague Dogs
It's only taken me around three decades to get round to reading this coruscating polemic by Richard "Watership Down" Adams, but it matched for quality of writing and sheer rage his underestimated "fluffy bunnies plus militarism, war crimes and abuse of power epic.
The eponymous dogs are escapees from a Lake District research facility - fleeing, one from repeated immersion in a "drowning tank", the other driven mad by brain surgery, into a harsh autumnal wilderness, trying to be wild and finding it no kinder an existence that domestic life, and hunted by men bent on their destruction.
The urgency required in their annihilation is provoked by the loathsome Digby Driver, a 1970s tabloid journalist of the scummy ilk still familiar today, but interesting as a character in the same way as Smeagol or Severus Snape, who makes the connection between the escaping dogs and bio weapons research conducted at the same facility to turn two sheep killers into carriers of lethal contagions. Mismanagement of media, official inertia and the knee jerks of publicity-aware politicians escalate a minor problem normally solved by one farmer, an early start and a loaded shotgun into a nationwide outcry and a regional panic.
In the midst of this human activity, our dogs try and fail to make a life for themselves. Aided sometimes by a self-interested fox who deploys their abilities to their mutual advantage, at other times our dogs know that they need a human master to survive, but that to approach men means a resumption of their tortures, or worse. As their condition slips to desperate, one of the dogs, blaming himself for the death of his kindly master, loses his grip on reality due to the mutilation of his brain.
This is described in Adams' mercurial prose, which switches from venom-fanged invective, to deliberately patronising Edwardian travelogue pap to prose verse. After the dogs kill their first sheep, he delivers a paragraph of prose verse rhyme with a rhythm familiar to contemporary rap connoisseurs, a triumphal screed which would not sound out of place in the microphones of a Tupac Shakur or a Wu Tang Clan. All Hail MC Richard, straight outta Oxford!
All these styles fuel Adams' incendiary condemnations of politicians, journalists, vivisectionists and mankind in general as abusers of those over who we hold dominion. But do not make the mistake of assuming you know the whole of Adams' mind on these matters - he baits the hooks of his rage with fat worms of indignation, only for the barbs of our own hypocrisy to gouge the throat as the denouement approaches. The ending of the book is unexpected and maybe bizarre, and Adams uses absurdity as a device which may not perhaps be appropriate to the rest of the book. But this moving, at time horrific, tale is fast-paced, thought-provoking and will make the reader angry on occasion, as the author intended. As a story of innate dignity of the helpless in the face of appalling cruelty and life becoming a landslide, as Richey said, this is a classic.
Friday, 11 June 2010
BP Woes
This is actually an old story, in terms of the economic, ecological and public relations carnage inflicted on the southern states of the US, but politically it's just starting to get interesting. For those who have been living on Mars for the last couple of months, a rig explosion in the Gulf of Mexcio has resulted in the leakage of hundreds of thousands of barrels of oil into the water, killing fish and shrimp, wrecking the economy of Louisiana and other states, destroying wildlife and ruining the tourist economy of the affected areas.
What makes this interest is that, despite the unresolved impacts of American firms such as Union Carbide and Eli Lilly, the involvement of US oil giant Halliburton and that of an American drilling firm (who must be at least partly culpable for the catastrophe), lame duck President Barack Obama, who promised so much and has delivered so little has decided that all the blame, all the vitreol (and all the financial loss) must be placed on the oil company whose pipeline ruptured, BP.
BP used to be British Petroleum, as Saint Barack keeps reminding his public. Of course, Barack hates us - we have always known this - so the chance to deflect attention from his own uselessness to his hated Brits was too good to pass up. He tells us his father was tortured by the British in Kenya, but then he told us he was born in Hawaii, and that might not be true, either. His behaviour towards Gordon Brown was so snubbish that I almost felt sorry for Useless Gordy. And rather than cultivate the alleged "Special Relationship" (a figment of the imagination of UK politicians with an eye on the US after-dinner speaking circuit), he has sought to build bridges with Europe, Russia and, er, the Islamic world. Thank God for Hillary Clinton's injection of credibility into Saint Barack's pisspoor foreign policy.
While the Americans are baying for BP's blood (or oil) let's take a step back from this. Despite the British media's insistence that 97% of Americans are in favour of nuking London tomorrow (a low figure compared to 98.4% in Yorkshire and 100% in Scotland), you have to Google pretty hard to find anti-British rhetoric linked to the BP crisis. And America's (but not Saint Barack's) anger towards BP is fully justified. Time (and enquiries) will eventually tell whether BP deserves all the blame.
What makes this interest is that, despite the unresolved impacts of American firms such as Union Carbide and Eli Lilly, the involvement of US oil giant Halliburton and that of an American drilling firm (who must be at least partly culpable for the catastrophe), lame duck President Barack Obama, who promised so much and has delivered so little has decided that all the blame, all the vitreol (and all the financial loss) must be placed on the oil company whose pipeline ruptured, BP.
BP used to be British Petroleum, as Saint Barack keeps reminding his public. Of course, Barack hates us - we have always known this - so the chance to deflect attention from his own uselessness to his hated Brits was too good to pass up. He tells us his father was tortured by the British in Kenya, but then he told us he was born in Hawaii, and that might not be true, either. His behaviour towards Gordon Brown was so snubbish that I almost felt sorry for Useless Gordy. And rather than cultivate the alleged "Special Relationship" (a figment of the imagination of UK politicians with an eye on the US after-dinner speaking circuit), he has sought to build bridges with Europe, Russia and, er, the Islamic world. Thank God for Hillary Clinton's injection of credibility into Saint Barack's pisspoor foreign policy.
While the Americans are baying for BP's blood (or oil) let's take a step back from this. Despite the British media's insistence that 97% of Americans are in favour of nuking London tomorrow (a low figure compared to 98.4% in Yorkshire and 100% in Scotland), you have to Google pretty hard to find anti-British rhetoric linked to the BP crisis. And America's (but not Saint Barack's) anger towards BP is fully justified. Time (and enquiries) will eventually tell whether BP deserves all the blame.
Thursday, 27 May 2010
Venter Plays God
So Craig Venter's "creation" of life is threatening to destroy the earth, or so a curious alliance of the Daily Mail and greenies would have us believe. In fact, all Venter has done is copy some DNA as a new strand and injected it into pre-existing cells - an impressive achievement but of itself not radical. In any case, far from bringing global germ warfare perilously closer, as the Mail and the veggie brigade would have us believe, it makes absolutely no difference. Maybe the Greens and Angry of Tunbridge Wells have never heard of smallpox, anthrax, Ebola, West Nile fever, typhus.... Whatever Venter may be guilty of, you can't blame him for stockpiling huge quantities of the above and weaponising them.
What exactly is Venter guilty of? The worst that anyone can say is that he mixes science with business. Considering that the man completed the human genome sequencing project in less than half the time projected by the academics who were planning to do the same thing, I'd say he has given the human race more than a decade's head start on preparing treatments and cures for genetic illnesses. How many lives has he saved? How many millions of man-years of suffering has he alleviated? More than the Mail's Paul Dacre, I'll bet.
What exactly is Venter guilty of? The worst that anyone can say is that he mixes science with business. Considering that the man completed the human genome sequencing project in less than half the time projected by the academics who were planning to do the same thing, I'd say he has given the human race more than a decade's head start on preparing treatments and cures for genetic illnesses. How many lives has he saved? How many millions of man-years of suffering has he alleviated? More than the Mail's Paul Dacre, I'll bet.
Friday, 7 May 2010
The Result and the Implications
Well, my prediction was wrong. The Tories failed by around 20 seats to procure the majority they needed to rid the country of Gordon Brown's inept leadership. Labour, in that self-deluding manner of theirs, have kidded themselves that the electorate, in refusing vote Cameron into Number Ten Downing Street, have instead endorsed a further period of Brownite rule, even though Labour trailed the Tories by 50 seats and 7% overall.
Indeed, the individual fluctations of fortune, if anything, shielded Labour from a further massacre. The Tories achieved swings of 11% in seats where a 3% swing would have won them the constituency, and swings of 5% where 6% was needed. A more even distribution would have cut the gizzard from the decomposing Labour party, in much the same way that even the slump to 23% suffered by Cleggy merited more than 50 seats over all. Electoral reform will be at the top of the agenda for whoever takes office.
Gordy, of course, remains PM until he resigns, and there is not much chance of that until a fresh election is called, either by a no-confidence vote (likely) or until due course forces an election after five years of dead duck governance. Labour, in Labour's view, has a moral right to retain office, possibly as part of a so-called "progressive alliance" of Labour and the LibDems.
In reality, that will not be sufficient. Labour and the Lib Dems between them can must only 315 of the 326 seats needed. 3 further seats will be available in the form of the Labour-affiliated SDLP in Ulster, but that will leave Brown 8 short. Sinn Fein's usual refusal to attend Westminster brings the threshold down to 323, so Gordy will need the 9 seats of the SNP-PC alliance to tip the scales in his favour.
Much was made on the pro-Labour BBC of the fact that, lacking any MPs in Ulster, and having only 1 in Scotland, the Tories would have no right to govern either of these countries. But, apart from Nick Robinson, no BBC hack was willing to express the converse opinion.
75% of Westminster's time is spent dealing with matters not affecting Scotland directly as these are devolved affairs, and Gordon Brown is de facto PM of England 75% of the time and PM of the UK the other 25%. For those wondering why Labour refused to establish an English legislature in 1999 to match those in Scotland and Wales, the following figures may enlighten:
Out of 533 seats in England, 297 declared for the Tories, 191 for Labour and 43 for the LibDems, a Tory majority of 63. If Blair had granted an English Parliament in 1999, that Parliament, the 50 million people it represented, and the bulk of the UK economy (including that part providing the subsidies for the Celtic nations) would have been in unshakeably Tory hands. Blair foresaw this day, and decided that England must remain forever shackled to a Celtic chain.
Yet 6 SNP and 3 PC MPs, representing no more than 900,000 Scottish and Welsh people, will hold the whip hand over one of the largest and richest nations in Europe. Given that the SNP and PC have NO mandate at all in England, complaints about the rectitude of Tory rule over Scotland and Wales seems rather hypocritical.
And if Brown is stupid enough to use the SNP and PC to support his miserable government, the inevitable cuts to English public services may at last persuade the English taxpayer to copy the rioting of their Greek counterparts.
Indeed, the individual fluctations of fortune, if anything, shielded Labour from a further massacre. The Tories achieved swings of 11% in seats where a 3% swing would have won them the constituency, and swings of 5% where 6% was needed. A more even distribution would have cut the gizzard from the decomposing Labour party, in much the same way that even the slump to 23% suffered by Cleggy merited more than 50 seats over all. Electoral reform will be at the top of the agenda for whoever takes office.
Gordy, of course, remains PM until he resigns, and there is not much chance of that until a fresh election is called, either by a no-confidence vote (likely) or until due course forces an election after five years of dead duck governance. Labour, in Labour's view, has a moral right to retain office, possibly as part of a so-called "progressive alliance" of Labour and the LibDems.
In reality, that will not be sufficient. Labour and the Lib Dems between them can must only 315 of the 326 seats needed. 3 further seats will be available in the form of the Labour-affiliated SDLP in Ulster, but that will leave Brown 8 short. Sinn Fein's usual refusal to attend Westminster brings the threshold down to 323, so Gordy will need the 9 seats of the SNP-PC alliance to tip the scales in his favour.
Much was made on the pro-Labour BBC of the fact that, lacking any MPs in Ulster, and having only 1 in Scotland, the Tories would have no right to govern either of these countries. But, apart from Nick Robinson, no BBC hack was willing to express the converse opinion.
75% of Westminster's time is spent dealing with matters not affecting Scotland directly as these are devolved affairs, and Gordon Brown is de facto PM of England 75% of the time and PM of the UK the other 25%. For those wondering why Labour refused to establish an English legislature in 1999 to match those in Scotland and Wales, the following figures may enlighten:
Out of 533 seats in England, 297 declared for the Tories, 191 for Labour and 43 for the LibDems, a Tory majority of 63. If Blair had granted an English Parliament in 1999, that Parliament, the 50 million people it represented, and the bulk of the UK economy (including that part providing the subsidies for the Celtic nations) would have been in unshakeably Tory hands. Blair foresaw this day, and decided that England must remain forever shackled to a Celtic chain.
Yet 6 SNP and 3 PC MPs, representing no more than 900,000 Scottish and Welsh people, will hold the whip hand over one of the largest and richest nations in Europe. Given that the SNP and PC have NO mandate at all in England, complaints about the rectitude of Tory rule over Scotland and Wales seems rather hypocritical.
And if Brown is stupid enough to use the SNP and PC to support his miserable government, the inevitable cuts to English public services may at last persuade the English taxpayer to copy the rioting of their Greek counterparts.
Friday, 30 April 2010
Bigots
Gordon Brown killed off Labour's chances of victory in the general election, not to mention his own career, with his off-the-cuff remarks about a pensioner he met on the hustings in Rochdale. The old lady in question asked where all the Eastern Europeans were coming from (one assumes Eastern Europe) and Brown, in the safety of the car, grumbled about the situation he had been put in by his handlers and denounced the old lady in question as "a bigoted woman".
Mainstream media picked over the comments at length and with more than a smidgeon of glee, other parties commented tersely and then moved on, while the comments boards of major media outlets were filled by very busy New Labour maggots posting repetetive comments asking "Since when has it been wrong to call a bigot a bigot"?
The question here is, were the original comments bigoted. It may seem bigoted to the sort of middle class privately educated twenty-somethings living in the better parts of the urban metropolises to question the provenance of immigrants moving not into the better parts of the urban metropolises but into bleak northern towns with little prosperity and few prospects, but then, with their Media Studies degrees and sinecures with Daddy's advertising firm, they will never really understand the concept of being pushed out of your job to make way for a Polish worker who will take £5k a year less than you, or of having your boss tell you that the alternative to you taking a pay cut, having your hours increased and your holidays reduced is for him to replace you with a Slovakian.
The fault lies not with the immigrants, of course, but the employers, who use the influx of cheap foreign labour as an excuse to lay off their British staff, saddled as they are with families and houses to maintain. The "bigotry" of Brown's "bigots" would be better directed towards these employers, who so often take the opportunity of illegal labour to welch on the National Insurance and Income Tax, and to pay less than the minimum wage - as this means that British workers cannot compete without breaking the law.
But the right-on Labour darlings infesting the comments sections of reports on CNN, the Guardian and every other news site you could name, for all their self-styled empathy with the Great Unwashed, will never have to deal with these problems. Rather than condemn the government's pathetic control of the UKs borders, or indeed the exploitative employers (after all, many of them are Daddy's friends), it is far easier to smear, Mandelson-style, the proles, who probably are all racist BNP voters.
One hopes that a Cameron victory will see this rabble of middle class turds rooted out of their public sector non-jobs. If they were to be replaced by Albanian asylum-seekers, that might increase their understanding of the plight of the uncultured Untermensch they share this country with.
Mainstream media picked over the comments at length and with more than a smidgeon of glee, other parties commented tersely and then moved on, while the comments boards of major media outlets were filled by very busy New Labour maggots posting repetetive comments asking "Since when has it been wrong to call a bigot a bigot"?
The question here is, were the original comments bigoted. It may seem bigoted to the sort of middle class privately educated twenty-somethings living in the better parts of the urban metropolises to question the provenance of immigrants moving not into the better parts of the urban metropolises but into bleak northern towns with little prosperity and few prospects, but then, with their Media Studies degrees and sinecures with Daddy's advertising firm, they will never really understand the concept of being pushed out of your job to make way for a Polish worker who will take £5k a year less than you, or of having your boss tell you that the alternative to you taking a pay cut, having your hours increased and your holidays reduced is for him to replace you with a Slovakian.
The fault lies not with the immigrants, of course, but the employers, who use the influx of cheap foreign labour as an excuse to lay off their British staff, saddled as they are with families and houses to maintain. The "bigotry" of Brown's "bigots" would be better directed towards these employers, who so often take the opportunity of illegal labour to welch on the National Insurance and Income Tax, and to pay less than the minimum wage - as this means that British workers cannot compete without breaking the law.
But the right-on Labour darlings infesting the comments sections of reports on CNN, the Guardian and every other news site you could name, for all their self-styled empathy with the Great Unwashed, will never have to deal with these problems. Rather than condemn the government's pathetic control of the UKs borders, or indeed the exploitative employers (after all, many of them are Daddy's friends), it is far easier to smear, Mandelson-style, the proles, who probably are all racist BNP voters.
One hopes that a Cameron victory will see this rabble of middle class turds rooted out of their public sector non-jobs. If they were to be replaced by Albanian asylum-seekers, that might increase their understanding of the plight of the uncultured Untermensch they share this country with.
Sunday, 25 April 2010
Access your MP
Went down to the next village along on Friday evening where outgoing MP was stumping for re-election. Asked a couple of questions, got some interesting answers and was generally impressed with his knowledge and connection with the issues. So much so, in fact, that I have decided I will vote for him after all.
All the palaver about the TV debates has helped to further obscure the fundamental point of our electoral system, which is that the voters are not voting for a Prime Minister or even a government, but for a man or woman who will listen to their concerns and protect their interests, even if that means going against the wishes of their own government. The people of Wyre Forest understood this when their local MP, a Labour party apparatchik, broke promises made to the electorate in order to further his party's interests and those of his own career. That's why they voted in an independent who has kept his promise to defend the hospital the Labourite undertook to keep open and then tried to close. The vitreolic attack launched by the Labourite against his former voters indicates that he also failed to understand the purpose of democracy, but then, he's not alone in his party on that score.
Most of the electorate, however, are under the impression that they are voting for Brown, Cameron or Clegg. So long as they make this basic and fairly easily amended error, they will continue to be piss-poorly represented by party workers parachuted in from London, who do not know or care what concerns their constituents have and will do or say whatever they need to to keep the office and the salary and the benefits flowing.
Brown, Cameron and Clegg do not need your vote to stay in the job, so they don't actually care what you think. Unless of course, you are one of the less-than 0.5% of the electorate actually represented by them in Parliament. Check out the candidates in YOUR constituency, choose the one you think will best represent your vision of the country, and once elected, make sure you keep them busy!
All the palaver about the TV debates has helped to further obscure the fundamental point of our electoral system, which is that the voters are not voting for a Prime Minister or even a government, but for a man or woman who will listen to their concerns and protect their interests, even if that means going against the wishes of their own government. The people of Wyre Forest understood this when their local MP, a Labour party apparatchik, broke promises made to the electorate in order to further his party's interests and those of his own career. That's why they voted in an independent who has kept his promise to defend the hospital the Labourite undertook to keep open and then tried to close. The vitreolic attack launched by the Labourite against his former voters indicates that he also failed to understand the purpose of democracy, but then, he's not alone in his party on that score.
Most of the electorate, however, are under the impression that they are voting for Brown, Cameron or Clegg. So long as they make this basic and fairly easily amended error, they will continue to be piss-poorly represented by party workers parachuted in from London, who do not know or care what concerns their constituents have and will do or say whatever they need to to keep the office and the salary and the benefits flowing.
Brown, Cameron and Clegg do not need your vote to stay in the job, so they don't actually care what you think. Unless of course, you are one of the less-than 0.5% of the electorate actually represented by them in Parliament. Check out the candidates in YOUR constituency, choose the one you think will best represent your vision of the country, and once elected, make sure you keep them busy!
Monday, 19 April 2010
Vulcanology
Vulcanology has nothing to do with Mr Spock. It is rather the study of volcanoes, such as the unpronounceaable one in Iceland which has grounded most of the planes in Europe.
For the uninitiated, volcanoes are mountains which form above hot spots in the earth's mantle, relieving build-up of gas and pressure, causing mayhem and misery to thousands of people planning to go abroad for their holidays. Now, I haven't been on a plane for 11 years and am not likely to be able to afford to go abroad for the foreseeable future, so I really couldn't care less, but it is interesting to note that it is not until day 5 that the government starts to think about how to get people stranded beyond railway's reach back home in time for term, voting, whatever. It is almost as if the government thought the volcano would 'blow over' in a couple of days like snow or a thunderstorm. Perhaps Gordon has been jabbing a map of Iceland with his finger while shouting "Stop! I command you to stop!" until the point at which he realised it wasn't working.
Reality time, guys. This eruption may continue for weeks. It might even go on for months. It might represent the start of a period of intermittent activity which could go on for decades.
Volcanoes do not respect government, general elections or the desires of the middle classes. This could mean the end of cheap, regular air travel as we know it.
For the uninitiated, volcanoes are mountains which form above hot spots in the earth's mantle, relieving build-up of gas and pressure, causing mayhem and misery to thousands of people planning to go abroad for their holidays. Now, I haven't been on a plane for 11 years and am not likely to be able to afford to go abroad for the foreseeable future, so I really couldn't care less, but it is interesting to note that it is not until day 5 that the government starts to think about how to get people stranded beyond railway's reach back home in time for term, voting, whatever. It is almost as if the government thought the volcano would 'blow over' in a couple of days like snow or a thunderstorm. Perhaps Gordon has been jabbing a map of Iceland with his finger while shouting "Stop! I command you to stop!" until the point at which he realised it wasn't working.
Reality time, guys. This eruption may continue for weeks. It might even go on for months. It might represent the start of a period of intermittent activity which could go on for decades.
Volcanoes do not respect government, general elections or the desires of the middle classes. This could mean the end of cheap, regular air travel as we know it.
Sunday, 18 April 2010
Liberal Democrats
The election got a whole lot more exciting after the first TV debate persuaded many that Clegg was fit to be PM, and I have to say that I am suddenly having doubts about what I thought was a cast iron dead cert prediction. The polls do seem to fluctuate wildly but the polls the media have fixated upon suggest that the LibDems are neck and neck with the Tories, with Gordon Brown's dying government crawling some distance behind. Other polls suggest that all three parties are tying, with the Tories slightly ahead and the LibDems trampling Labour to te bottom of the heap.
If this trend is representative of what is happening in the marginals, then all bets are off. The LibDems have taken vote share from both of the other major parties, which suggests that people who vote tactically and negatively are voting positively for Clegg's party. In other words, instead of holding their nose to keep their least favoured party out, they are voting FOR someone.
The danger inherent in this is that, barring a major swing towards one party, this guarantees a hung parliament. The Tories will not be able to form a working coalition - Clegg has already ruled out any deals with the Tories, although not in so many words - so those who switched from the Tories to get Brown out of Downing Street to the LibDems are helping to ensure that Gordy gets back into Downing Street - either as PM or Chancellor - so he can continue his wrecking spree.
Those whose priority is to stop this will probably switch their vote back to Cameron, which means the Tories will scoop up seats weakened by Labour's poll losses to Clegg, and potentially might end up with a bigger majority than might otherwise have happened.
If this trend is representative of what is happening in the marginals, then all bets are off. The LibDems have taken vote share from both of the other major parties, which suggests that people who vote tactically and negatively are voting positively for Clegg's party. In other words, instead of holding their nose to keep their least favoured party out, they are voting FOR someone.
The danger inherent in this is that, barring a major swing towards one party, this guarantees a hung parliament. The Tories will not be able to form a working coalition - Clegg has already ruled out any deals with the Tories, although not in so many words - so those who switched from the Tories to get Brown out of Downing Street to the LibDems are helping to ensure that Gordy gets back into Downing Street - either as PM or Chancellor - so he can continue his wrecking spree.
Those whose priority is to stop this will probably switch their vote back to Cameron, which means the Tories will scoop up seats weakened by Labour's poll losses to Clegg, and potentially might end up with a bigger majority than might otherwise have happened.
Friday, 16 April 2010
The Big Debate
So the first debate is out the way, and reaction is mixed. The clash between Brown, Cameron and Cleggy may have been somehwat stilted, with pre-arranged questions and dozens of match rules limiting the scope for ad lib and reaction, and the three protagonists threw pre-arranged attacks at each other.
On the other hand, it seemed a lot more real and honest than a Parliament's worth of PMQs and a book bin full of manifestoes. Consensus is that all three did ok, that Clegg was the star of the show and if anything Cameron underperformed.
That's as may be, but it misses the point. Stick Nigel Benn and Chris Eubank in the ring and it is obvious what's at stake - the first man to lay his opponent on hs back for more than ten seconds gets a nice new belt to wear. But Clegg, Brown and Cameron were all playing for different reasons.
Gordon Brown knows that there is, barring massive electoral fraud, no chance of Labour getting anything like a working majority, so his strategy was to undermine his principle opponent and woo his most likely coalition partner in the event of a hung Parliament. He stuck to the attack-Cameron-suck-up-to-Clegg strategy fairly consistently, if somewhat clunkingly, at times.
Clegg, by contrast, knows that Brown cannot do without him and so felt free to attack both Cameron and Brown for their parties' records. He knew that Brown would have to swallow the insult. It also gave the impression that the LibDems will be willing to deal with either party, which is a fiction given that he pretty well ruled out setting up shop with the Tories a few weeks ago. Apart from one dog-snapping-at-spaghetti moment, when he struggled to answer one point (about the economy, if I recall), he seemed full of vigour and vinegar.
Cameron knew that the election is his to lose - stick to the script and don't cock it up and he may squeak a Commons majority. Screw up and he lets Gordon back in as head of a LibLab coalition. So his strategy was to charm the audience and not to take the inevitable bait (Eddie Izzard's pathetic performance on tonight's Party Propaganda broadcast shows how Labour plans to fight this election) while trying not to look too tight and controlled.
So nobody really made a tit of themself, apart from Clegg's waffle moment, Cameron's cringemaking anecdote about how he spoke to "a black man" and Gordon's quite frightening gurning attempt at smiling.
On the other hand, it seemed a lot more real and honest than a Parliament's worth of PMQs and a book bin full of manifestoes. Consensus is that all three did ok, that Clegg was the star of the show and if anything Cameron underperformed.
That's as may be, but it misses the point. Stick Nigel Benn and Chris Eubank in the ring and it is obvious what's at stake - the first man to lay his opponent on hs back for more than ten seconds gets a nice new belt to wear. But Clegg, Brown and Cameron were all playing for different reasons.
Gordon Brown knows that there is, barring massive electoral fraud, no chance of Labour getting anything like a working majority, so his strategy was to undermine his principle opponent and woo his most likely coalition partner in the event of a hung Parliament. He stuck to the attack-Cameron-suck-up-to-Clegg strategy fairly consistently, if somewhat clunkingly, at times.
Clegg, by contrast, knows that Brown cannot do without him and so felt free to attack both Cameron and Brown for their parties' records. He knew that Brown would have to swallow the insult. It also gave the impression that the LibDems will be willing to deal with either party, which is a fiction given that he pretty well ruled out setting up shop with the Tories a few weeks ago. Apart from one dog-snapping-at-spaghetti moment, when he struggled to answer one point (about the economy, if I recall), he seemed full of vigour and vinegar.
Cameron knew that the election is his to lose - stick to the script and don't cock it up and he may squeak a Commons majority. Screw up and he lets Gordon back in as head of a LibLab coalition. So his strategy was to charm the audience and not to take the inevitable bait (Eddie Izzard's pathetic performance on tonight's Party Propaganda broadcast shows how Labour plans to fight this election) while trying not to look too tight and controlled.
So nobody really made a tit of themself, apart from Clegg's waffle moment, Cameron's cringemaking anecdote about how he spoke to "a black man" and Gordon's quite frightening gurning attempt at smiling.
Thursday, 15 April 2010
An Important Day
I had planned to use today's post to pick apart the manifestos of Cam and Cleggy, particularly Cameron's worrying idea to allow ordinary members of the public a greater say in running the country (yes, that means your neighbour, the one with shaved head and the tattoos), but something far more important has happened today, an event which kind of puts the Big Debate into the shade.
I'm talking about Simon Singh's court victory over the British Chiropractic Association, which isn't just one man's victory over a censorious organisation, or of commercial interest over journalistic licence, but a linked victory of freedom of speech over censorship, and of scientific rationalism over the creeping stifling of debate in the UK by the forces of religious reaction and obscurantism.
In short, Simon Singh questioned the methods and motives of individuals who make their living peddling healthcare-based claims with absolutely no scientific basis. The BCA sued him to silence him. Once upon society, realising the benefits that science and technology brought, would have laughed the BCA out of court. "You want to make money out of the gullible by claiming that twiddling with people's backbones cures asthma, prove it!"
No longer. Complementary medicines are available on the NHS, paid for out of budgets which might be better deployed using demonstrably efficacious medicines. Tony Blair has permitted the utter non-science of "intelligent design" to be taught in UK schools. Religious and other cultural norms are allowed to trump education, healthcare and even public order. And with the BCA's attack on Singh, the alliance of religion, superstition and ignorance hoped to set a precedent which would allow them to operate unchallenged among an increasingly uninformed public.
However, the judge allowed Singh to use the "fair comment" defence - in other words, confirming indirectly that Singh has the right to free speech. Seeing that their aim - to stifle free speech - had thus been denied by the court, the BCA folded. If Singh's comments were "fair comment" as indeed they were, and as the generation before ours would have taken for granted, then the BCA could not win. So they surrended.
Good for Simon Singh! His victory gets his chestnuts out of the fire, but his stemming of the tide of snake-oil science is only a small step. Given that homeopathy continues to thrive (and be paid for by you) despite numerous controlled trials which show that homeopathic cures work no better than placebos, superstition and ignorance will be with us for a long time to come.
I'm talking about Simon Singh's court victory over the British Chiropractic Association, which isn't just one man's victory over a censorious organisation, or of commercial interest over journalistic licence, but a linked victory of freedom of speech over censorship, and of scientific rationalism over the creeping stifling of debate in the UK by the forces of religious reaction and obscurantism.
In short, Simon Singh questioned the methods and motives of individuals who make their living peddling healthcare-based claims with absolutely no scientific basis. The BCA sued him to silence him. Once upon society, realising the benefits that science and technology brought, would have laughed the BCA out of court. "You want to make money out of the gullible by claiming that twiddling with people's backbones cures asthma, prove it!"
No longer. Complementary medicines are available on the NHS, paid for out of budgets which might be better deployed using demonstrably efficacious medicines. Tony Blair has permitted the utter non-science of "intelligent design" to be taught in UK schools. Religious and other cultural norms are allowed to trump education, healthcare and even public order. And with the BCA's attack on Singh, the alliance of religion, superstition and ignorance hoped to set a precedent which would allow them to operate unchallenged among an increasingly uninformed public.
However, the judge allowed Singh to use the "fair comment" defence - in other words, confirming indirectly that Singh has the right to free speech. Seeing that their aim - to stifle free speech - had thus been denied by the court, the BCA folded. If Singh's comments were "fair comment" as indeed they were, and as the generation before ours would have taken for granted, then the BCA could not win. So they surrended.
Good for Simon Singh! His victory gets his chestnuts out of the fire, but his stemming of the tide of snake-oil science is only a small step. Given that homeopathy continues to thrive (and be paid for by you) despite numerous controlled trials which show that homeopathic cures work no better than placebos, superstition and ignorance will be with us for a long time to come.
Monday, 12 April 2010
That Manifesto in Full
Gordon says: No extension of VAT to categories of items not currently liable to VAT. That's not the same as no increase in VAT, no matter that he tried to deflect attention from this loophole by slating the Tories for their historic increases of VAT. "The Tories doubled VAT *GAPE*" he said, referring to events which happened so long ago that while we are trying to focus on this remote Tory tax hike, he'll be slipping a 1-2% VAT rise past our political myopia.
Gordon says: Targetted cuts and 'fair' taxes will enable me to half the budget deficit. The deficit that happened when "Financial Whizz" Gordon fell asleep at the wheel and crashed the economy.
Gordon says: Parents of children at underperforming schools will have the power to sack the management of that school. The fact that this will remove the onus from HMG and allow them to pass the blame to the public when our creaking education system finally collapses under its burden of bureaucracy and idiotic targets is not important, of course.
Gordon says: Every young person to have education till 18. Including special needs pupils, who then have to pay for vocational training when they have finished 2 extra years of remedial education. This was brought in by Labour. Nice.
Gordon says: There will be a cap on the costs of residential care for the elderly. What the cap actually is depends on what money is left in the pot when free residential care for the elderly in Scotland is paid for.
Gordon says: English tests for immigrants working in the public sector. What? Even doctors?
Gordon says: A referendum on changing the electoral system to Proportional Representation. This is SO obviously bait for Nick Clegg to come out and declare that he is joining an anti-Tory electoral coalition. Gordy obviously remembers how Tony Bliar not-quite-promised Paddy Pantsdown's LibDems a place in government. Ashdown and his followers lapped it up, and their positioning helped Bliar to bury the moribund Tories. No place at the top table was forthcoming, however. Hope you're reading this, Cleggy!
Gordon says: Votes for 16 year olds! From what I heard on "Any Answers" on Saturday, this is a widely supported strategem to capitalise on teenage lefty idealism to boost LibLab votes. What if they demand the right to lower legal ages for a host of activities currently not accessible to them. Hey kids, give the "Porn, Booze and Driving Party" your immediate support.
Gordon says: Strict controls on high street loan companies and doorstop lenders. what about high street banks lending to people beyond their means to repay. Didn't that happen recently?
Gordon says: High speed rail links to connect London to major cities in England and Scotland. I presume Salmond's Scottish executive, having responsibility for transport policy north of the border, will foot the bill for the Scottish part of this rail link. After all, is it fair for the English taxpayer to upgrade Scotland's transport network in time for the SNP to declare independence?
In short, this is a basket of policies remedial for the mess that Labour have caused over 13 years, policies aimed at increasing their votes, policies aimed at gulling the LibDems into playing Gordy's little helper, and vote-winning policies which Labour have no intention of implementing.
It could be worse. Let's see if the others can do worse.
Gordon says: Targetted cuts and 'fair' taxes will enable me to half the budget deficit. The deficit that happened when "Financial Whizz" Gordon fell asleep at the wheel and crashed the economy.
Gordon says: Parents of children at underperforming schools will have the power to sack the management of that school. The fact that this will remove the onus from HMG and allow them to pass the blame to the public when our creaking education system finally collapses under its burden of bureaucracy and idiotic targets is not important, of course.
Gordon says: Every young person to have education till 18. Including special needs pupils, who then have to pay for vocational training when they have finished 2 extra years of remedial education. This was brought in by Labour. Nice.
Gordon says: There will be a cap on the costs of residential care for the elderly. What the cap actually is depends on what money is left in the pot when free residential care for the elderly in Scotland is paid for.
Gordon says: English tests for immigrants working in the public sector. What? Even doctors?
Gordon says: A referendum on changing the electoral system to Proportional Representation. This is SO obviously bait for Nick Clegg to come out and declare that he is joining an anti-Tory electoral coalition. Gordy obviously remembers how Tony Bliar not-quite-promised Paddy Pantsdown's LibDems a place in government. Ashdown and his followers lapped it up, and their positioning helped Bliar to bury the moribund Tories. No place at the top table was forthcoming, however. Hope you're reading this, Cleggy!
Gordon says: Votes for 16 year olds! From what I heard on "Any Answers" on Saturday, this is a widely supported strategem to capitalise on teenage lefty idealism to boost LibLab votes. What if they demand the right to lower legal ages for a host of activities currently not accessible to them. Hey kids, give the "Porn, Booze and Driving Party" your immediate support.
Gordon says: Strict controls on high street loan companies and doorstop lenders. what about high street banks lending to people beyond their means to repay. Didn't that happen recently?
Gordon says: High speed rail links to connect London to major cities in England and Scotland. I presume Salmond's Scottish executive, having responsibility for transport policy north of the border, will foot the bill for the Scottish part of this rail link. After all, is it fair for the English taxpayer to upgrade Scotland's transport network in time for the SNP to declare independence?
In short, this is a basket of policies remedial for the mess that Labour have caused over 13 years, policies aimed at increasing their votes, policies aimed at gulling the LibDems into playing Gordy's little helper, and vote-winning policies which Labour have no intention of implementing.
It could be worse. Let's see if the others can do worse.
Sunday, 11 April 2010
The Race Begins
Nearly a week in and already things are hotting up. My prediction is that after a couple of weeks of slow haemorrhaging of the Labour vote, there will be a last minute swing stampede from the LibDems to the Tories, who will win an overall majority of 35-40 seats.
A number of factors dictate this eventuality. First, Nick Clegg made a statement a couple of weeks back in which he more or less ruled out the possibility of the LibDems going into coalition with the Conservatives, so the electorate basically has a choice of Tories or Labour-plus-someone else. While those who support the LibDems for ideological reasons will likely stick with their principles, those who don't like the Tories but think that another five years of Gordon Browns hamfisted management of the economy would be disastrous are likely to see Clegg's speech as meaning that a vote for the LibDems will have precisely that result and will hold their noses and vote Tory. We saw something similar in 1992 - Labour were ahead in the polls in an election I planned to abstain from, but a last minute vision of Kinnock standing in the doorway to number 10, grinning and waving like an orang-utan in a cheap suit, forced me to vote Tory. (It also had the added pleasure of making the man who held his victory parade 2 days' before the poll was actually held look something of a prat.)
In addition to this, I confidently predict there will be widescale electoral fraud involving postal ballots. Most of this will be in Birmingham, with added pockets in Manchester, Leicester and Bradford. Some will involved ballots taken from people by their "community leaders" (read into that what you will) while others will be intercepted and sold to these "electoral agents" by bent posties. Expect re-counts and acrimony, and I will add that most, but not all, of these frauds will benefit the Labour party.
Just a hunch, you understand.
A number of factors dictate this eventuality. First, Nick Clegg made a statement a couple of weeks back in which he more or less ruled out the possibility of the LibDems going into coalition with the Conservatives, so the electorate basically has a choice of Tories or Labour-plus-someone else. While those who support the LibDems for ideological reasons will likely stick with their principles, those who don't like the Tories but think that another five years of Gordon Browns hamfisted management of the economy would be disastrous are likely to see Clegg's speech as meaning that a vote for the LibDems will have precisely that result and will hold their noses and vote Tory. We saw something similar in 1992 - Labour were ahead in the polls in an election I planned to abstain from, but a last minute vision of Kinnock standing in the doorway to number 10, grinning and waving like an orang-utan in a cheap suit, forced me to vote Tory. (It also had the added pleasure of making the man who held his victory parade 2 days' before the poll was actually held look something of a prat.)
In addition to this, I confidently predict there will be widescale electoral fraud involving postal ballots. Most of this will be in Birmingham, with added pockets in Manchester, Leicester and Bradford. Some will involved ballots taken from people by their "community leaders" (read into that what you will) while others will be intercepted and sold to these "electoral agents" by bent posties. Expect re-counts and acrimony, and I will add that most, but not all, of these frauds will benefit the Labour party.
Just a hunch, you understand.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)